What the fading means
The BMJ analysis of 23 trials found that very-low-carb diets produced clinically important weight loss among people who adhered to them, and much less among those who did not. Its authors listed long-term dietary satisfaction among the open questions.
That is a finding about human beings, not about carbohydrate. Any plan that depends on willpower at every meal has a shelf life.
Where keto has an edge
When the National Lipid Association reviewed low-carb diets, it found they were not superior to other diets for weight loss, but may have advantages for appetite control and for reducing medication in type 2 diabetes. Being less hungry is not a small thing when you are trying to keep going for years.
Then there is the menu. Ribeye with creamed spinach. Salmon with crisp skin. A cheeseburger casserole. Eggs and bacon. For a lot of men this is a list of things they wanted to eat anyway, with the bread taken away.
Where it fights you
The first week can be rough, with tiredness and headaches while your body adjusts. Our keto flu lesson covers it. Eating out and drinking with friends take more thought. LDL cholesterol rises in some people. And with diabetes medication involved, you cannot start on a whim.
If keto turns out not to be for you, that is not failure. The American Diabetes Association supports several eating patterns, and the best one is the one you keep.