Hosting Thanksgiving? Get the free keto game plan.

Men with diabetes / Where keto fits / The case for keto

The Diet That Works Is the One You Keep

In the trials, low-carb diets for type 2 diabetes were clearly ahead at six months and roughly level by twelve. The diets did not stop working. People stopped following them. So the practical question is not which diet is best on paper. It is which one you will still be eating next year.

Check this first. If you take insulin, a sulfonylurea or an SGLT2 inhibitor, cutting carbs without your prescriber can be dangerous. Talk to them before you change what you eat. Read the medication page.

What the fading means

The BMJ analysis of 23 trials found that very-low-carb diets produced clinically important weight loss among people who adhered to them, and much less among those who did not. Its authors listed long-term dietary satisfaction among the open questions.

That is a finding about human beings, not about carbohydrate. Any plan that depends on willpower at every meal has a shelf life.

Where keto has an edge

When the National Lipid Association reviewed low-carb diets, it found they were not superior to other diets for weight loss, but may have advantages for appetite control and for reducing medication in type 2 diabetes. Being less hungry is not a small thing when you are trying to keep going for years.

Then there is the menu. Ribeye with creamed spinach. Salmon with crisp skin. A cheeseburger casserole. Eggs and bacon. For a lot of men this is a list of things they wanted to eat anyway, with the bread taken away.

Where it fights you

The first week can be rough, with tiredness and headaches while your body adjusts. Our keto flu lesson covers it. Eating out and drinking with friends take more thought. LDL cholesterol rises in some people. And with diabetes medication involved, you cannot start on a whim.

If keto turns out not to be for you, that is not failure. The American Diabetes Association supports several eating patterns, and the best one is the one you keep.

Try it this week

Free · take it to your doctor

The Doctor’s Brief

A printable page for your next appointment: your medications, the questions to ask before you cut carbs, and a 14-day log.

No spam, ever. Unsubscribe in one click. By subscribing you agree to our privacy policy.

The evidence

What this page is based on

Each source with what it found and where it falls short. Nearly all of this research is in type 2 diabetes.

Goldenberg et al., BMJ, 2021

A pooled analysis of 23 randomized trials (1,357 people with type 2 diabetes) of low- and very-low-carbohydrate diets lasting at least 12 weeks.

What it found. At six months, 57% of people on low-carb diets had an HbA1c below 6.5%, against 31% on comparison diets, with large improvements in weight, triglycerides and insulin sensitivity.

The limits. The advantage was smaller when remission meant being off medication, was much weaker in studies that included people on insulin, and had largely faded by 12 months, when there were also signs of worse LDL cholesterol. Very-low-carb diets did well only among people who stuck to them.

Kirkpatrick et al., Journal of Clinical Lipidology, 2019

A National Lipid Association task force reviewing recent systematic reviews and meta-analyses.

What it found. Low-carb and very-low-carb diets are not superior to other diets for weight loss. They may have advantages for appetite control, triglycerides and reducing medication in type 2 diabetes.

The limits. Effects on LDL cholesterol were mixed, with increases in some studies, and there is little data beyond two years.

American Diabetes Association consensus report, Diabetes Care, 2019

An expert panel convened by the American Diabetes Association, reviewing the nutrition research for adults with diabetes.

What it found. Reducing overall carbohydrate intake has the most evidence for improving blood glucose. For select adults with type 2 diabetes, low- or very-low-carbohydrate eating plans are a viable approach, and they have been shown to reduce A1C and the need for glucose-lowering medication.

The limits. It supports several eating patterns, not one, and says the choice should fit the person. It found no qualifying trials of these patterns in adults with type 1 diabetes.

Quick answers

Is keto better than a Mediterranean diet for diabetes?

The American Diabetes Association does not rank them. Low-carb has the most evidence for lowering blood glucose in the short term. Choose the one you can live with, and tell your doctor which it is.

Do I have to count everything?

Mostly just carbs. A written menu does the counting for you, which is the reason the playbook exists.

General information, not medical advice. It does not diagnose, treat or cure diabetes or any other condition, and results vary. Never start, change or stop a medication without your prescriber. See our health disclaimer.

The Long Game · the playbook

Two weeks, planned for you

A 14-day keto menu with total carbs and net carbs on every dish, a one-page brief for your doctor, and a log for your meter readings. Built to be used with your doctor, not instead of one.

  • 14 days of menus with total carbs, net carbs and protein for every meal
  • 36 recipes and two shopping lists
  • The medication checklist and the Doctor’s Brief
  • A 14-day log for readings, meals and walks

Get the playbook — $19See everything inside

Instant PDF download. 14-day satisfaction guarantee. A meal plan, not a medical treatment. Never change a medication without your prescriber.