Hosting Thanksgiving? Get the free keto game plan.

Men with diabetes / What men should know / Fact 3

Weight Loss and Remission: What the DiRECT Trial Found

The strongest evidence on remission of type 2 diabetes is about weight, not about any one diet. In the DiRECT trial, 46% of people on a structured weight-management program were in remission after a year, against 4% with usual care. Among those who lost 15 kg or more, it was 86%.

Check this first. If you take insulin, a sulfonylurea or an SGLT2 inhibitor, cutting carbs without your prescriber can be dangerous. Talk to them before you change what you eat. Read the medication page.

What DiRECT did

Forty-nine family practices in Scotland and northern England enrolled 306 adults who had been diagnosed with type 2 diabetes within the previous six years and were not using insulin. Half the practices offered a weight-management program. The other half gave best-practice care.

The program was not keto. It was a low-calorie formula diet for three to five months, then a stepped return to food, with long-term support. Diabetes and blood pressure drugs were withdrawn at the start, under medical supervision.

What happened

After 12 months, 46% of the program group were in remission, meaning an HbA1c below 6.5% while off all diabetes medication for at least two months. In the usual-care group it was 4%.

Remission tracked weight loss closely. Nobody who gained weight was in remission. Of the 36 people who lost 15 kg or more, 86% were.

What it means for keto

That weight is the lever, and the method is your choice. The American Diabetes Association's consensus report puts numbers on it: 5% weight loss is recommended for clinical benefit in type 2 diabetes, the benefits are progressive, and 15% or more is the goal where it can be done safely.

Keto is one way to get there, and a way a lot of men find easy to live with. It is not the only way, and anyone who tells you otherwise is selling something.

Who was not in the trial

People on insulin, and people who had had diabetes for more than six years. The trial cannot tell us what would happen for them, which is one reason not to put the conversation with your doctor off.

This week

Free · take it to your doctor

The Doctor’s Brief

A printable page for your next appointment: your medications, the questions to ask before you cut carbs, and a 14-day log.

No spam, ever. Unsubscribe in one click. By subscribing you agree to our privacy policy.

The evidence

What this page is based on

Each source with what it found and where it falls short. Nearly all of this research is in type 2 diabetes.

Lean et al. (the DiRECT trial), The Lancet, 2018

306 adults in UK primary care who had been diagnosed with type 2 diabetes in the previous six years and were not on insulin.

What it found. After a year on a structured weight-management program, 46% were in remission (HbA1c below 6.5% off all diabetes medication), against 4% with usual care. Among those who lost 15 kg or more, 86% were in remission.

The limits. The program was a low-calorie formula diet with medical support, not keto. It shows that weight loss drives remission, by whatever method.

American Diabetes Association consensus report, Diabetes Care, 2019

An expert panel convened by the American Diabetes Association, reviewing the nutrition research for adults with diabetes.

What it found. Reducing overall carbohydrate intake has the most evidence for improving blood glucose. For select adults with type 2 diabetes, low- or very-low-carbohydrate eating plans are a viable approach, and they have been shown to reduce A1C and the need for glucose-lowering medication.

The limits. It supports several eating patterns, not one, and says the choice should fit the person. It found no qualifying trials of these patterns in adults with type 1 diabetes.

Riddle et al., Diabetes Care, 2021

An international expert group convened by the American Diabetes Association.

What it found. The group chose remission as the right word, and an HbA1c below 6.5% measured at least three months after stopping glucose-lowering medication as the usual test.

The limits. It is a definition, not a result. The group noted that the long-term risks and benefits of reaching remission are not well understood.

Quick answers

Is remission the same as a cure?

No. Remission means your blood sugar is back in the normal range without medication. It can come back, particularly if the weight does, and you still need regular check-ups.

Do I have to do a formula diet like the trial?

No. The trial shows that weight loss drives remission. How you lose the weight is between you and your doctor.

General information, not medical advice. It does not diagnose, treat or cure diabetes or any other condition, and results vary. Never start, change or stop a medication without your prescriber. See our health disclaimer.

The Long Game · the playbook

Two weeks, planned for you

A 14-day keto menu with total carbs and net carbs on every dish, a one-page brief for your doctor, and a log for your meter readings. Built to be used with your doctor, not instead of one.

  • 14 days of menus with total carbs, net carbs and protein for every meal
  • 36 recipes and two shopping lists
  • The medication checklist and the Doctor’s Brief
  • A 14-day log for readings, meals and walks

Get the playbook — $19See everything inside

Instant PDF download. 14-day satisfaction guarantee. A meal plan, not a medical treatment. Never change a medication without your prescriber.