What has actually been tested
Two small trials have looked at ketogenic diets and breathing during sleep. In one, 20 patients with obesity hypoventilation syndrome ate keto for two weeks. Their sleep apnea severity and overnight oxygen improved and they lost 3.4 kg. There was no comparison group, and the main benefit faded when they went back to their usual diet.
In the other, 70 patients with obesity and sleep apnea used CPAP for four weeks, half of them with a low-calorie keto diet added. Breathing pauses improved in both groups, and the diet added nothing extra on that measure, though the keto group lost weight and lowered their blood pressure.
Neither study measured snoring in ordinary men at home. That study has not been done.
What is well supported
Weight is. In a four-year study of 690 adults, a 10% weight loss went with about 26% fewer breathing pauses, and a 10% gain with about 32% more. Imaging studies show where the benefit comes from: less fat around the throat, in the tongue and on the belly.
Evening alcohol is too. It makes snoring worse on the night you drink it, whatever you weigh. Losing weight and avoiding alcohol near bedtime are the first two things sleep clinics tell people who snore.
So why keto at all?
Because the weight has to come off somehow, and it has to stay off. When the National Lipid Association reviewed the evidence, it found low-carb diets were not superior to other diets for weight loss, but may have an advantage for appetite control.
In plain terms: keto is not magic, but being less hungry makes any diet easier to keep, and the menu is steak, salmon, eggs and butter. If that is the way of eating you will still be following in three months, it is the right one for you. If you would rather lose the weight another way, your airway will not know the difference.
Who should not expect much
Men who are already lean. Men whose snoring comes from a blocked nose, a deviated septum or the shape of their jaw and palate. And anyone with signs of sleep apnea, who needs a doctor first and a diet second.