Hosting Thanksgiving? Get the free keto game plan.

Men with diabetes / Where keto fits / The label

Total Carbs or Net Carbs? Which Number to Count With Diabetes

Keto recipes, including ours, count net carbs: total carbohydrate minus fiber. The American Diabetes Association does not recognize the term, because fibers and sugar alcohols do not all behave the same way. If you have diabetes, look at both numbers, and let your meter settle any argument.

Check this first. If you take insulin, a sulfonylurea or an SGLT2 inhibitor, cutting carbs without your prescriber can be dangerous. Talk to them before you change what you eat. Read the medication page.

Where net carbs come from

Fiber is a carbohydrate your body mostly does not turn into glucose, so low-carb eaters subtract it. Many also subtract sugar alcohols such as erythritol. The result is the net figure, and it is how every recipe on this site is counted.

What the ADA says

The Association's guidance is that net carbs has no legal definition, is not used by the FDA, and is not recognized by the ADA. Its reason is practical: the sum is not entirely accurate, because how much a fiber or sugar alcohol contributes depends on which one it is.

Some sugar alcohols, maltitol in particular, raise blood sugar more than the label arithmetic suggests. Our hidden-carb library goes through them one by one.

What to do with both numbers

For whole foods such as vegetables, nuts and avocado, net carbs is a reasonable guide. For packaged foods with a big net-carb claim on the front, trust the total on the nutrition panel and read the ingredient list.

That is why the Long Game menus show total carbs alongside net carbs for every dish. If you count carbs to dose insulin, use whichever number your diabetes team has taught you to use, and nothing else.

The meter is the referee

A guide for family doctors recommends structured testing, such as a reading before a meal and another afterward, as a quick way to see how a food affects you. Ask your doctor how often you should test, and whether your prescription covers enough strips.

This week

  • Paste a label into the label decoder and see what is hiding in it.
  • Check the sweetener in anything labeled sugar-free.
  • Ask your doctor whether paired before-and-after readings make sense for you.
Free · take it to your doctor

The Doctor’s Brief

A printable page for your next appointment: your medications, the questions to ask before you cut carbs, and a 14-day log.

No spam, ever. Unsubscribe in one click. By subscribing you agree to our privacy policy.

The evidence

What this page is based on

Each source with what it found and where it falls short. Nearly all of this research is in type 2 diabetes.

American Diabetes Association: Get to Know Carbs

Patient guidance from the American Diabetes Association.

What it found. The term net carbs has no legal definition and is not used by the FDA or recognized by the American Diabetes Association, because fibers and sugar alcohols do not all behave the same way in the body.

The limits. General guidance, not a study.

Murdoch et al., British Journal of General Practice, 2019

A practical guide written for family doctors by five clinicians.

What it found. Sulfonylureas and insulin usually need to be reduced or stopped when a patient cuts carbs, because blood glucose typically falls substantially. SGLT2 inhibitors carry a risk of ketoacidosis that can occur with normal blood glucose. Metformin, GLP-1 drugs and DPP-4 inhibitors pose no excess risk, and blood pressure medication may need adjusting too.

The limits. It is guidance for prescribers, based on clinical experience and how the drugs work, not a trial. It is not a set of instructions for patients.

Quick answers

Which number do your recipes use?

Every recipe shows net carbs, and the recipe pages list total carbs and fiber too. The Long Game menus show total and net carbs side by side.

Are keto bars and sugar-free candy safe for diabetes?

Treat them with suspicion. Many rely on maltitol or added fibers, which can raise blood sugar more than the net-carb number implies. Check the ingredient list, and check your meter.

General information, not medical advice. It does not diagnose, treat or cure diabetes or any other condition, and results vary. Never start, change or stop a medication without your prescriber. See our health disclaimer.

The Long Game · the playbook

Two weeks, planned for you

A 14-day keto menu with total carbs and net carbs on every dish, a one-page brief for your doctor, and a log for your meter readings. Built to be used with your doctor, not instead of one.

  • 14 days of menus with total carbs, net carbs and protein for every meal
  • 36 recipes and two shopping lists
  • The medication checklist and the Doctor’s Brief
  • A 14-day log for readings, meals and walks

Get the playbook — $19See everything inside

Instant PDF download. 14-day satisfaction guarantee. A meal plan, not a medical treatment. Never change a medication without your prescriber.